logo

U.S. PIRG Consumer Blog

« Airline gotcha fees up, hearing today | Main | IRS brings you identity theft, fraud and predatory lending »

April 11, 2008

Nursing Homes "Kill Old People Cheap"

Recently, a Tennessee legislator labeled a proposal backed by the nursing home industry the "Kill Old People Cheap Act" (Knoxville News Sentinel). The bill would cap damages and force consumers into binding mandatory arbitration to resolve disputes, as a condition of admission.

Today's Wall Street Journal has a page one story by Nathan Koppel called Nursing Homes, in Bid to Cut Costs, Prod Patients to Forgo Lawsuits (pd. subs. req'd) explaining how nursing homes are among the leading users of arbitration, but that all the other corporations on the block are doing it, too. Excerpt:

The nursing-home industry's arbitration strategy is part of a much broader response by U.S. companies to consumer lawsuits. Businesses from restaurants to banks have ramped up their use of arbitration agreements in recent years to reduce litigation costs and sidestep emotion-laden juries, often requiring employees or consumers to give up rights to a trial as a condition of receiving services. Studies have suggested about a third of businesses are requiring arbitration for consumer disputes, and about one-fifth of employers are requiring it for complaints by employees.
This week, Senators Mel Martinez (R-FL) and Herb Kohl (D-WIN) introduced legislation banning pre-dispute mandatory arbitration in nursing home contracts: The Fairness in Nursing Home Arbitration Act, S.2838. (The bill text isn't coming up yet, but that should be the link.) This blog entry from last fall links to a series by Charles Duhigg of the New York Times on how nursing home chains are using complex legal structures designed to hide their absentee investment firm owners from liability for sub-standard care. U.S. PIRG and other consumer groups are strong supporters of binding arbitration reform (one blog, another blog). In addition to focused bills such as this nursing home bill, Senator Russ Feingold (D-WI) and Rep. Hank Johnson (D-GA) have introduced the Arbitration Fairness Act, which would ban pre-dispute binding mandatory arbitration in all consumer (and many other) contracts. Check your cell phone or credit card or health club or health insurance contract-- you've probably agreed to limit your legal rights many times.

Posted by Ed Mierzwinski at April 11, 2008 06:43 AM


Comments

Post a comment




Remember Me?



218 D. Street, SE Washington, DC 20003
Phone (202) 546-9707

E-mail: