|
U.S. PIRG Consumer Blog
« Consumer groups petition FDIC on improving plastic protections-is your money insured? |
Main
| Proposal from Treasury: Text of draft bailout agency law »
September 20, 2008
Treasury proposes massive rescue plan, consumer groups will insist on help for homeowners
The New York Times reports in a story by David Herszenhorn on its website on Saturday: Rescue Plan Seeks $700 Billion to Buy Bad Mortgages. The amount is staggering as the story points out: A $700 billion expenditure on distressed mortgage-related assets would be roughly what the country has spent in direct costs on the Iraq war and more than the Pentagon’s total yearly budget appropriation. It represents more than $2,000 for every man, woman and child in the United States. But worse, the problem with the headline words "bad mortgages" is that peculiar wording in the story -- it is actually bad "mortgage-related assets." As Joe Nocera reports in his story Hoping a Hail Mary Pass Connects in Saturday's New York Times, whatever the government is buying this time, as opposed to when it established the successful Resolution Trust Corporation during the late 1980s-early 1990s savings-and-loan-bailout, it isn't actually real estate, it is a bunch of complicated securities instruments derived from real estate and of "uncertain value:"
Most of the assets in the S.& L. crisis were real estate — which are always going to have value. And the government didn’t have to acquire them; it simply took them over and, over time, sold them. This time, the assets are complex derivatives of uncertain value that the big firms will actually be selling to the government. But how is the government going to assess these securities — and what price will it pay for them? In many cases, these securities aren’t being sold because they are still overvalued on a firms’ books. Consumer and community groups, including U.S. PIRG, are insisting that the Congress demand that the package under consideration include a provision ignored in the summer's housing bailout law. The Congress must give bankruptcy judges the authority to adjust the terms of certain subprime mortgages to prevent foreclosures and allow consumers to remain in their homes. As for other details of any bailout package, the Congress should start by reviewing this outline from the economist Dean Baker. Also, the Center for Responsible Lending has proposed several things that Congress can do now, including granting authority to bankruptcy judges to prevent foreclosures. While the government must stop the bleeding, let's make sure that the proposal protects depositors, homeowners, taxpayers and small (average people like you and me) investors first, as a first principle.
Posted by Ed Mierzwinski at September 20, 2008 01:08 PM
Post a comment
|